- Small group vs whole class instruction isn't an either-or choice. Whole-class time builds shared core knowledge, and small groups meet specific needs.
- Bill Metz keeps core instruction and adds 30 minutes of reading and 30 minutes of math each day for small-group intervention or enrichment.
- Small groups work best when every student gets one, not only the lowest scorers.
- Let assessment data decide who goes in which group, and keep checking it.
- Keep groups small. At Bill Metz, they run 10 students or fewer.
- Pool specialists and grade-level teachers into one team so small groups don't require extra staff.
- Share the load. As Gabe puts it, you don't have to do it all.
Ask a room of teachers about small group vs whole class instruction and you'll probably get a debate. Gabe Futrell's answer is more practical: use each one for what it does best.
Gabe has been principal of Bill Metz Elementary in Monte Vista, Colorado, for 15 years. It's a small, rural, high-poverty school that was recognized for strong post-pandemic growth. On the EdisonOS Podcast, he walked us through how his team splits the day between regular core instruction and daily small-group time, and how assessment data decides who works with whom.
In this post, we look at what each approach is good for, what the research says, and how a school can decide when to use each one.
Small group vs whole class instruction: what each does best
The two approaches solve different problems, so the real question is what job you need done.
Whole-class instruction is the natural home for core, grade-level content. Everyone hears the same ideas at the same time, uses the same vocabulary, and builds on the same foundation. It's efficient, and it keeps a grade level moving together. Bill Metz leans on that shared foundation. Gabe's team lines up instruction vertically, so kindergarten through second grade are all preparing students for third grade CMAS, not just the third grade teachers.
Small-group instruction does something whole-class teaching can't. A teacher can watch how each student works through a problem, catch a misunderstanding early, and adjust right away. That's why it's the go-to format for intervention. It's also useful for enrichment, when a student is ready to go further than the core lesson allows.
So the choice isn't small group vs whole class instruction as rivals. It's about matching the format to the need.
How Bill Metz uses both every day
Gabe's school doesn't swap one format for the other. It layers them. Every student gets regular core instruction, and on top of that, every student gets 30 minutes of reading and 30 minutes of math a day in what the school calls IE time, short for intervention and enrichment.
What stands out is who gets the small group. Gabe was clear on the EdisonOS Podcast: "It wasn't students that were just the lowest or just the highest that were getting pulled to meet their specific needs. It was every student in every grade level."
The group sizes come from the staffing. Special education, English language learner, gifted and talented, and Title I teachers all join one intervention team, and grade-level teachers join them during the 30-minute block. Picture a grade level with 100 students and 10 teachers. Instead of four teachers each running a group of 25, you get groups of 10 or fewer.
The school started IE time just before COVID, adjusted it during the pandemic, and kept it. Gabe credits it with significant gains in reading and math. He also admits the idea wasn't original. His team visited another school, saw the model working, and adopted it.
What the research says about small-group instruction
The evidence supports using both formats, with a clear role for small groups.
The U.S. Institute of Education Sciences (IES) reading practice guide for the primary grades recommends differentiated reading instruction for all students based on assessments of their current reading levels, plus intensive small-group instruction on up to three foundational skills for students who score below the benchmark. Its math practice guide for grades K-6 focuses on effective small-group interventions for students who struggle.
A large randomized trial in Norway tested what Gabe describes. Across 159 schools, 7 to 9 year olds were pulled from regular math classes into small groups of 4 to 6 for three to four hours a week during two periods of four to six weeks each year. Unlike many tutoring studies, all students were pulled out, not only struggling ones. Students in treatment schools improved their national test performance by 0.06 standard deviations, with no differential effect by baseline score, parental education or gender.
Group size and frequency matter too. A meta-analysis of 89 randomized tutoring studies found a pooled effect of 0.288 standard deviations, with the largest effects for programs in earlier grades, held at least three days a week and during school. Bill Metz's daily schedule fits that pattern, although its groups of 10 or fewer are larger than the smallest groups in the tutoring research.
Scale and targeting matter as well. When Metro Nashville Public Schools delivered more than 125,000 hours of tutoring to over 6,800 students, researchers found a small positive effect in reading (0.04 to 0.09 standard deviations) and no average effect in math. The program followed a set grade-level curriculum instead of personalizing content to each student's diagnostic results, and the authors suggested that better targeting could raise the effects. In other words, putting students in small groups isn't enough. What happens in the group has to match what each student needs.
Use assessment data to decide who goes in which group
Small groups only work when the grouping is right, and that's where assessment data comes in. Bill Metz builds its groups from i-Ready and NWEA MAP results, which come back the same day or the next. Gabe told us that every student gets "exactly what they need according to the data," no matter whether they're on a formal plan or what their gender or ethnicity is.
Because results come back fast, groups can change quickly. A student who masters a skill moves on, and a student who needs more time stays. Colorado's READ Act builds in the same rhythm for the early grades. It requires interim assessments for every K-3 student three times each school year to identify students with a significant reading deficiency, and an approved diagnostic assessment within 60 calendar days when a student scores below the cut score.
One caution from Gabe: in a small school, a single student can swing a grade level's numbers, so look at trends across several years before reading too much into any one result.
The same logic applies to older students. At EdisonOS, our diagnostic tests and score reports show skill and sub-skill gaps, so a teacher or tutor can group students by what they need next, whether they're preparing for the Digital SAT or the ACT.
Make small groups work without adding staff
The biggest objection to small-group instruction is staffing. Gabe's answer is to rethink how existing adults are scheduled. In a small district like his, about 80 percent of funding goes to salaries and benefits, which leaves roughly 20 percent for programs, technology and everything else. There's no room to hire a new person for every group.
So Bill Metz puts specialists and grade-level teachers in the same 30-minute block, so every available adult is working with a small group at the same time.
He also leans on shared leadership. Speaking on the EdisonOS Podcast, he said the idea behind distributive leadership is that "you don't have to do it all, you shouldn't do it all." A school that builds leadership across its staff has more people who can run groups well.
Finally, he's careful about funding. If a grant pays for a position, there has to be a plan to sustain it, since it will eventually come out of the general fund.
When whole-class instruction is still the right call
None of this makes whole-class teaching obsolete. Gabe's view of test preparation shows why. He says good prep shouldn't look different the week before a test than it does all year, and it relies on core instruction that's lined up across grade levels. That's shared, whole-grade work.
Whole-class instruction is the better fit when:
- You're introducing a new concept that every student needs.
- Most students are working at a similar level on the skill.
- You want a shared vocabulary and common experience before students split into groups.
Small groups are the better fit when:
- Assessment data shows students need different next steps.
- A skill gap needs frequent practice with quick feedback.
- Some students are ready for more challenge than the core lesson offers.
The best schedule uses both, with the data deciding when to switch.
Final thoughts
Small group vs whole class instruction doesn't need a winner. Bill Metz shows how to keep the shared core and add daily, data-driven small groups for every student. Gabe's advice for new principals applies here too: keep a small focus, have grace for yourself and others, and have some fun every day.
At EdisonOS, we work with schools, tutoring companies and community organizations that want to turn assessment results into a clear next step for every student. Our guide on how diagnostic tests personalize prep goes deeper on using results to plan instruction.
Ready to see it in action? Start a free trial, book a demo, or take a free practice test for the Digital SAT or the ACT. To hear more from Gabe, listen to the full conversation on the EdisonOS Podcast.
-Picsart-AiImageEnhancer.png)


